On academic resistance and organised complicity  

On academic resistance and organised complicity  

In June 2024, we took part in the Central-Eastern Europe International Studies Association (CEEISA) convention, co-organised with the International Studies Association (ISA), in Rijeka. Since the conference program did not feature any panels/roundtables on the ongoing genocide in Gaza, we – together with colleagues – sought to organise a series of solidarity actions during the conference. Our modest intervention turned the three days into one of the strangest and most tense academic events we have ever partaken in. To contextualize the events for those who were not at CEEISA-ISA in Rijeka, below we first reflect on the silence and silencing of academic institutions and conferences in times of genocide, as well as the confronting oblivion of our epistemic community, the meaning(s) of solidarity, and friendships and colleagues in IR. We then use this event to ask whether acts of protest in institutions clearly comfortable with such silences (or actively and violently silencing protests and discussions) are a productive intervention. Instead of repeatedly speaking to the academic beast that does not want to hear, see and act, should we withdraw our, often free, labor from said institutions and redirect our energy and actions elsewhere? Shouldn’t we make these violent institutions irrelevant through a collective action of rejection and redirection of labor instead of continually re-legitimizing them with our demands and even our anger?

Amidst an ongoing, almost 20-month-long, livestreamed genocide, or rather in Amitav Ghosh‘s words–omnicide – the destruction of all life and the conditions that make life possible – in Gaza, we all are expected to just carry on with life like business as usual. Such cognitive dissonance has caused so much stress, anger, disbelief, and anguish to humans the world over. As Isabella Hammad rightly suggests, “[t]he present onslaught leaves no space for mourning, since mourning requires an afterwards, but only for repeated shock and the ebb and flow of grief. We who are not there, witnessing from afar, in what ways are we mutilating ourselves when we dissociate to cope? To remain human at this juncture is to remain in agony.”

It is precisely that agony that compels us–as humans, as scholars, as people from a region that has itself experienced genocide during our lifetimes–to push back against the “business as usual” approach many of our colleagues seem to have adopted. A part of humanity being entirely destroyed, under the political, financial and military cover of the West, demands from scholars of International Relations (IR) to move beyond the convenient cop-out of “it is too complex” and take a principled stand and action.

Within this context, we were and are inspired, and sustained, by the students’ encampments, activist organisations, labor unions, writers, and (extra)ordinary people and communities around the world who have raised their voices, and engaged in material actions, against the genocide. Likewise, our inspiration comes as well from some of our IR colleagues who have pushed their institutions [1] and associations [2] to either put an end to their complicity in the genocide against the Palestinians – be it through partnerships with the defense industry, through collaboration with the Israeli state directly or with Israeli universities which have themselves enabled the current genocide – or at the very least, express solidarity. 

In the context of the conference we attended, one might ask what Central-Eastern Europe (CEE) has to do with it. Why does this matter to “us”, as it is unfolding “far away from us”, as some colleagues in Rijeka suggested? As we have argued in our motion sent to CEEISA-ISA after the conference, the ongoing livestreamed genocide reveals the historical and present-day ties, solidarities, and structural complicities that have existed between the CEE region and Palestine/Israel; and it is our responsibility as scholars to learn from the past, including about the role academic institutions and academics have played in laying the ground work for genocide. At a conference that brought together scholars from and of the former Yugoslavia in such large numbers, the genocidal groundwork laid down by the Serbian Academy of Sciences and Arts in the former Yugoslav space in the 1980s and 1990s, needs no introduction to make these connections explicit.

As the conference was taking place in the post-Yugoslav space, we think it is particularly critical to meaningfully reflect on the importance of academic and intellectual silence and complicity in the face of genocide, and interlinked projects of white supremacy, racialisation and ‘othering’. Here we would be remiss not to stress that, as Edward Said suggested in Orientalism, academic and cultural institutions in the ‘Global North’ have long been complicit in projects of power and oppression, from colonialism, to the “unseen ways in which mechanisms of race and imperialism condition not only peoples, but also knowledge and practice” including through foreign policy. Academic silence and silencing on Palestine is the latest iteration of structural harms our institutions of higher learning are perpetuating, as explored by Steven Salaita in his recent book.

In our particular case, even though our academic work as a Collective and individually is primarily focused on the post-Yugoslav space, we do not conceive of ‘our region’ as detached from the rest of the world, nor are we oblivious to political developments in the world, their immediate impact on our region notwithstanding, as we explain in our October 2023 statement of solidarity with the Palestinian people.

No conferencing as usual during genocides!

In June 2024, three of us – members of the Yugoslawomen+ Collective, Elena B. Stavrevska, Sladjana Lazić and Vjosa Musliu, headed to the CEEISA-ISA conference in Rijeka, Croatia, a place often described as the “city of solidarity”. The conference was titled “Knowing the global-local: imagining pasts, debating futures”. Our panel was on “The Post-Yugoslav Space in and of IR” and problematized the co-constitutive relationship between IR as a discipline and the post-Yugoslav space. Our panel, in conversation with Siddharth Tripathi and Katarina Kušić, is a small part of a book we are writing as a Collective where we, building on works of so many others before us, tease the potential of small, “peripheral”, or “insignificant” regions to theorize IR and contribute to worldmaking of IR. While this was our primary contribution to the conference as a Collective, individually, we were also participating in other panels on Russia’s war against Ukraine or knowledge production in IR in times of crisis. 

Our contributions aside, when the program of the conference was published, we noticed that there were no panels or roundtables on the ongoing genocide in Gaza and Palestine, the plethora of panels on peace and conflict studies notwithstanding (unlike, for instance at the earlier British International Studies Association conference, held in June 2024, which included several panels and roundtables on Palestine). This is despite the conference’s call explicitly listing contributions on “decentring and recentring global knowledge production through regional epistemic frameworks and practices”, “war in (re-)making knowledge”, “relations between the Global Norths, Global Souths, and Global Easts, including varieties of racialisation, the role of political economy”, “varieties of dissent knowledges, the politics of memory, and the narration of histories”, among others. We are aware that the lack or presence of specific panels/roundtables that eventually make it to the conference program is often not directly linked to the conference organizers, but is dependent on the submissions that were put forward. For us, it was intellectually implausible, analytically lazy, and problematic from a human standpoint to have a significant portion of the Western and Eastern European epistemic IR community gathered at a three-day conference to theorize, problematize, and strategize about war and peace without properly grappling with, or at the very least, acknowledging the ongoing genocide in Gaza.  

That said, while organizers cannot control the submissions, there is certainly something to be said about who or what was platformed during the conference-sponsored key events, and to question whether talking about genocide in Gaza more explicitly in such events was avoided intentionally. For example, during the opening plenary session and the keynote address, senior scholars expressed dismay at students showing solidarity with Palestinians, rather than Ukrainians, thus perpetuating the broader global trends which problematise the protestors instead of the perpetrators and enablers of genocide. They also suggested our goal as scholars should be to exchange thoughts, not “slogans” (even though many of those who claim to be “exchanging thoughts” are actually frequently exchanging slogans themselves, not willing to question their own terminology), and to discipline affect and emotions in International Relations. As methodologically implausible and politically problematic as that sounds, it is clear that protests and “slogans” are allowed and encouraged for certain wars and conflicts, but not for Palestine. 

In light of the conference programme, together with friends and colleagues who were en route to Rijeka, we organised a couple of solidarity actions during the conference – No conferencing as usual during genocides! – to reaffirm solidarity with Palestine and demand institutional action and response from the CEEISA leadership. In addition to publishing this on our website, we also shared the same on our social platforms. In terms of actions, we first sought, and asked others as well, to use our panel/roundtable time to talk about the ongoing violence of Israel against Palestinians. Next, we organised three actions during lunch breaks in the premises of the Civil Engineering building where the conference was taking place. 

Concretely, on June 19, we organised a spontaneous discussion on academic freedom, the role and responsibility of academics/intellectuals, censorship, and violent suppression of the students’ encampments around the world, and with a particular focus on CEE countries and academic institutions. Some friends and colleagues joined us during our first event, many others did not. It was, arguably, a very small gathering given the size of the conference. It is worth noting here that as we entered the lobby of the building, there was increased campus security – as many as four private security guards in a rather small space – who, at Elena merely pulling out a scarf with the Palestinian flag, immediately rushed to us and asked her to remove the scarf or they would have to call the police. We refused to comply with their request and asked the guards why they were making this demand in an attempt to reason with them. However, our efforts were largely unsuccessful, with one saying, “we have called the police; you can continue this conversation with them.” We can only speculate about what transpired after and the reasons for the police never arriving, but in the end, the scarf remained and the guards stepped back to observe from a distance. 

Among the people who joined our action that day was also Professor Gordan Jelenić, full professor at the Faculty of Civil Engineering and vice-rector at the University of Rijeka, who earlier this year, following the traditional “Night March” on the 8th of March, was detained and fined for displaying a Palestinian flag during the march, even though march organizers had called for a show of support for Palestinians whose human rights have been under threat. The alleged basis for the police actions against Professor Jelenić was article 26 of the Law on Offenses against Public Order and Peace in Croatia, which forbids the display of other states’ flags without “a general invitation of a socio-political organization or without the approval of the administrative body responsible for internal affairs”. The ridiculousness of this argument is shown not only in the fact that the organizers had published “a general invitation”, but even more so by the fact that Croatia does not recognize Palestine as a state. 

The following day, on June 20, a lot more people showed up, including some perhaps only out of curiosity. We decided to talk about the links and solidarities between CEE and the ongoing omnicidal violence, perpetuated by Israel against Palestinians in Gaza. We were joined by our colleagues Catherine Baker who talked about Eurovision and the politics of culture in the making of ‘Middle East’ and Paul Stubbs who talked about the connections and solidarities between Palestine and the former Yugoslav space forged during the Non-Aligned Movement (NAM). Stubbs mentioned thousands of African and Asian students who studied in Yugoslavia, especially during Yugoslavia’s membership in NAM; a good number of Palestinian pilots, doctors and nurses as well as professors were educated in former Yugoslav cities and even today, many of those who work in Gaza’s beleaguered hospitals studied in Zagreb or other Yugoslav cities. Socialist Yugoslavia, as one of the leaders of NAM, was instrumental in the recognition of Palestine as a full NAM Member State in 1975, paving the way for the Arab League to do the same a year later; post Cold-war friendships and communities between Palestinians and Muslim subjects from the former Yugoslav space were continued during Hajj visits, anti-apartheid and anti-war solidarities in the 1990s; the first prime minister of the short-lived all-Palestine Government established in the Gaza Strip in 1948, Ahmed Hilmi Pasha, was of Albanian descent.

As we continued to (un)learn as a Collective about said solidarities and complicities thereafter, it is necessary to note that before its NAM membership, Yugoslavia contributed to the settler colonial project before and after the establishment of Israel: from 1946, it collaborated with Mossad LeAliyah Bet in the illegal transit of around 50,000 Jewish settlers to Palestine and it also supported weapons supply chains to Israel between 1948 to 1953. Despite being one of the first three European countries (along with Czechoslovakia and Poland) to recognize Israel in 1948, Yugoslavia did not maintain official diplomatic relations after 1967, although there were secret contacts with Israel between 1967 and 1990. Following Yugoslavia’s breakup, the successor states established their own bilateral relations with Israel. 

The diplomatic relations between Belgrade, as a capital of the FR Yugoslavia, and the state of Israel were renewed in 1992, and it has been a matter of “public secret” that the state of Israel exported ammunition and rifles, as well as provided training, for the forces of Serbia and Republika Srpska during the 1990s wars, long after the UN Security Council introduced an arms embargo. The 2016 appeal of an Israeli academic and lawyer to disclose the defense exports between Israel and Serbia during the 1990s was rejected by Israel’s Supreme Court, stating “that disclosure of the requested information may harm national security or foreign relations”. The nature of relations between Serbia and Israel (including, but not limited to, a long list of Israeli figures who have been involved in organized denial of the Srebrenica genocide) has come under scrutiny more recently due to repeated reports about an increase of Serbian arms exports to Israel during an ongoing genocide. Some of the historical solidarities, however, continue to this day across CEE, and have been expressed through statements and actions. 

It was during these discussions in Rijeka that one of the conference participants who had joined out of curiosity (or, an intention to provoke?), shockingly suggested that “genocide is a technical concept and should not be used lightly” (indeed, none of us used it lightly!), while another countered the criticism towards what was said during the opening plenary by suggesting we were “angry because [our] voice is not the only voice.” There was a further comment that CEEISA has not so far issued solidarity statements, “even for wars that are closer to us”, in reference to Russia’s full-scale invasion of Ukraine. To put it in other words, we were being told that somehow, a continued pattern of silence in terms of official declarations is a norm that IR scholars of CEEISA – many of whom work on peace and conflict studies no less – cannot break. 

On June 21, we held a moment of silence in vigil for our Palestinian colleagues killed by Israel in the first 9 months of the current genocide, holding pictures of fellow academics from Palestine. This vigil, again rather small, unfolded with some of our other colleagues having lunch near us, catching up on emails or chatting with friends, while actively averting their gaze from what was happening next to them. Quite the poignant mini-representation of the majority of Western academia and their always-averting gaze, ever more evident since October 2023! As others have said before, Palestine has become a magnifying glass exposing raw those who have routinely engaged with ‘critical research’ and ‘activism’ merely for self-aggrandizement or whose ‘decolonial’ work suddenly could not be replicated in any shape or form in the case of Palestine.

Later that day, at the end of the CEEISA General Assembly, two minutes before our own panel was meant to start, we were given the floor to tell the Assembly about this “demand by the Yugoslawomen+ Collective”. The demand, which did not come solely from us as a Collective but a bigger group of colleagues, was for the CEEISA membership to vote on a motion that at the very least acknowledges the present omnicidal violence in Gaza. In one breath, with one foot out the door on the way to the very panel for which we came to Rijeka in the first place, we made the case for why this is important in general and why it must be important to us as IR scholars and scholars of the CEE region. We missed the subsequent discussion, but we were afterwards told that a decision was made for us to draft the motion and submit it for consideration.   

In the aftermath of the conference 

A couple of months after the conference, 16 of us submitted a motion to CEEISA membership to be put forward for a formal vote via electronic ballot, as per Article 6 (iv) of the CEEISA Charter, which foresees voting taking place via electronic ballot. The motion essentially called for CEEISA to acknowledge the scholasticide in Gaza in line with the call by Gaza academics and university administrators.

By any measure, this is hardly a controversial or even a very ambitious motion. It is, we would argue, a mere acknowledgement, the proverbial lowest-hanging fruit. And yet, when the motion was finally put to a vote in February 2025 – after the Executive Council’s approval in November 2024 and two members of the Council resigning over this decision – fewer than 20 percent of the membership even cast a vote. 

Even though the overwhelming majority of those who voted were in favour, the motion did not meet the 20 percent participation threshold by a single vote, and ultimately did not pass. Even though the CEEISA leadership in the meantime had published a “statement on the rising threats to universities and academic freedom worldwide,” this outcome left us wondering where we go from here, in the face of such blatant disregard and disengagement. It also left us wondering how, if at all, to respond to the IR scholarly organisations that have used an approach of active silencing of solidarity with Palestinians and voices who have pointed out the complicity in the current genocide committed by Israel.

Redirecting our labor and actions 

Before and after Rijeka, we were and continue to be horrified by the silences and even more by the fact that some IR scholarly associations not only remained silent but also worked actively to suppress any possible dialogue on and expression of solidarity with Palestinians. The actions of the International Studies Association leadership, who have not only remained entirely silent on the genocide against Palestinians, but have also “actively censor[ed] its members through antidemocratic governance, and with punitive actions against section and caucus leaders” who have tried to initiate discussions on the issue, are a case in point. Calls for the ISA to take a stand, including a motion against scholasticide and for boycott, divestment, and sanctions, have been dismissed and, quite literally, silenced.

To be clear, both the silences and the active suppression of solidarity with our Palestinian colleagues who are targets of scholasticide, and raising our voice against genocide did not only start in these organisations with October 2023, nor with the second Trump administration, but have a much longer history. For instance, researchers trace increasing suppression of Palestine solidarity on North American campuses back to at least 2008, whilst other researchers also point to a suppression of Palestine solidarity in Germany that long preceded 2023. In the UK context, this suppression can be traced to being a longstanding part of the ‘political fabric’ often targeting negatively racialized minorities. The suppression of solidarity and activism against genocide has become ever more evident since October 2023 in countries such as the US, UK, Germany, Austria, as well as many other Central and Eastern European states. It has been particularly evident in the targeting of student protests and encampments, from disciplinary actions, suspensions to deportations, often based on spurious claims. 

So where does this leave us? Should we even be asking what role IR academics, associations, and universities should, or rather must play in the face of genocides? Shouldn’t that be obvious? What does our duty of care towards our students who are protesting look like? Can IR conferences become anything more than “feel-good” gatherings where certain topics and realities are, in Sara Ahmed’s words, kill-joys per definition? Do academic associations have any potential to contribute to the moral and intellectual consciousness in and of IR? 

Much has already been written about the ongoing disciplinary silencing and scholarly avoidances, and/or deliberate disengagement from and open complicities with the ongoing genocide against Palestinians. Pratt and colleagues (2024) wrote about the troubling silence of the Western feminists, others wrote about “the role of sociology in times of genocidal violence and settler colonialism, and an attempt to bridge the disconnect between the values of the discipline”, Fellegi and Pali (2025) wrote about the restorative justice movement’s role during an unfolding genocide, Lazic and Stavrevska (2024) about peace studies, Gani (2024) wrote and talked about unseeing genocide and Gaza and the Liberal International (Dis)Order, and many others wrote and talked about their respective disciplines neeeding to speak up. 

Most of the abovementioned texts were published in peer-reviewed journals, in addition to many solidarity statements, protest letters, and BDS motions (in many of which we took part) written addressing different aspects and parts of what we call the neoliberal academic beast and its complicity with the ongoing genocide. Students and (some) faculty have been putting their bodies, as well as their visas, resident permits, and livelihoods, between the police baton and a chant of solidarity for months now. Israel has continued to slaughter and burn alive Palestinians in Gaza and terrorize those in the occupied Palestinian territories. And yet, the academic beast has not flinched. 

Academia, as a deeply colonial institution that perpetuates academic imperialism through imposition of Western models and erasures of Indigenous knowledges, has always already been on the side of the violent status quo through its disciplining of resistance against oppressions into palatable disagreement over differences in opinion. We knew that long before October 2023. 

Yet, we still keep trying to get the academic beast, or the academic industrial complex, to merely acknowledge the obvious, while Israel keeps murdering and starving people in Gaza and Palestine. Even our acts of academic resistance (if this is nothing but a contradiction in terms!) – the published articles, teaching, the statements, the conference protests – serve to keep feeding and even providing bits and pieces of ‘post-factum re-legitimization’ of the academic beast. And yet, we are still collectively in shock and disbelief at our own impotence to make the beast flinch. If we still hold on to the conviction that, in the words of Stuart Hall, “the university is a critical institution or it is nothing”, could it be that the last 20 months have shown us the urgency to refuse, instead of address, the walls of the Ivory Tower altogether?

Instead of feeding the beast with our written words, labor and even with our anger, frustrations, resignations, and feelings of impotence, why don’t we withdraw our (most often unpaid) labor and energies from it, either through a collective strike or smaller acts of refusal? Why not redirect that labor and energy into the movements that are in the streets, into the creation of other spaces of collective learnings, such as the Workshops for Gaza, resistance, such as the Popular University for Gaza, and/or contributing teach-outs at student encampments? Instead of begging the beast to reform itself, why don’t we simply make it irrelevant through our collective rejection and redirection of labor?  
Just as importantly, given the most recent ‘trend’ in attempts to leave some rhetorical (and still very far from any material action) bread crumbs for the future redemption and whitewashing of their complicity by politicians and public figures, we can soon expect the ‘for-nearly-20-months-silent’ academics to start again jumping on the decolonial bandwagon. As Omar El Akkad wrote: “One day, when it’s safe, when there’s no personal downside to calling a thing what it is, when it’s too late to hold anyone accountable, everyone will have always been against this.” It is our duty to hold the institutions and people accountable for their silences and complicities, and to be diligent in not confusing reckoning with acts of careerism that bravely talk about ‘a topic of genocide’ only ‘in the past tense’.

[1] Faculty of Social Sciences at the University of Ljubljana, Peace Institute of Ljubljana, among others.

[2] British International Studies Association, British Society for Middle Eastern Studies, European International Studies Association, Middle East Studies Association, and the Native American and Indigenous Studies Association, to name a few.

Categories: Analysis, Solidarity